Neonchameleon
Legend
Ratings for Player and DM respectively:
Assuming Essentials, 7/6 - I'm using this as my baseline.
6/8
5/7
4/4
Hard to rate - not a good introduction but simple if you are familiar with RPGs.
6/5 (i.e. one step lower than 4e).
3/4
7/8
8/8? Possibly higher? And I was highly unimpressed by the number of details needed for a supers game.
Also I'd add recommendations for the shelves for some of the Fighting Fantasy line and Dread.
Here are the RPGs we are listing:
Dungeons and Dragons (4th edition)
Assuming Essentials, 7/6 - I'm using this as my baseline.
Pathfinder
6/8
World of Darkness (nWoD)
5/7
Doctor Who: Adventures in Time and Space
4/4
Savage Worlds
Hard to rate - not a good introduction but simple if you are familiar with RPGs.
Gamma World (4e-based)
6/5 (i.e. one step lower than 4e).
Leverage
3/4
Traveller (Mongoose edition)
7/8
Mutants and Masterminds (3rd edition)
8/8? Possibly higher? And I was highly unimpressed by the number of details needed for a supers game.
Also I'd add recommendations for the shelves for some of the Fighting Fantasy line and Dread.