DEFCON 1 said:And those extra 30 seconds it takes to hit the '2' button to go to the next page is enough to drive some people away screaming from the boards?
Err... yes. It's something those of us who do web design or web programming (and I'm the latter) very much have to deal with -- every additional click you require is one that a certain percentage of people won't follow. You don't make things harder for the end user without a very, very good reason.
And the nonfunctional subscription page adds a lot of inconvenience to following -- and running -- PBP games.