Season 5's American Idol: Katherine or Taylor?

[Darth K'Trava]

I was totally all for Taylor as well. Even when Chris was on there... Katharine just got on my nerves. She wrecked alot of the songs she had. She sang OVER Meatloaf in the finale. I think the only reason she got that far was because she was the only female left and they wanted a male/female show-off at the end; hence why they got rid of Chris and Elliott.

I'd rather they'd kept Paris on there than Katharine the Song Wrecker.

 

[Remus Lupin]

On the subject of Meatloaf. It's true that Katherine sang over him, but ... but ... I mean, Meatloaf was really, really, Really bad. It was like a musical grenade thrown into my living room. I had to resist the urge to throw myself on it to protect my wife and kids.

 

[Goodsport]

On the subject of Meatloaf. It's true that Katherine sang over him, but ... but ... I mean, Meatloaf was really, really, Really bad. It was like a musical grenade thrown into my living room. I had to resist the urge to throw myself on it to protect my wife and kids.

Even still...

Katherine McPhee most of the time =

Katherine McPhee during her duet with Meatloaf =

-G