Wik
First Post
Did someone just quote DOGMA!? I'm especially surprised that it's you, the guy who so rarely watches movies.
Should A Paladin's Holy Weapon Be Limited To Swords?
- Thread starter Quantum
- Start date
Did someone just quote DOGMA!? I'm especially surprised that it's you, the guy who so rarely watches movies.
A Greyhawk Deity of Paladins, Heironeous, originally specialized in the Battleaxe. This was introduced and written by EGG in Dragon, then added to the WoG boxed set.
3e forced him to take up the longsword. But if you are looking for precedent of Holy Weapons not being swords, that's the key one.
3e forced him to take up the longsword. But if you are looking for precedent of Holy Weapons not being swords, that's the key one.
coyote6
Adventurer
If you're playing 3e, then the holy weapon ability can be placed on any weapon -- swords, axes, bows -- heck, if your GM lets you have a magical M134 7.62mm minigun, you can make it holy, too, and do an extra 2d6 damage to evil targets at 4000 rounds per minute.
The holy sword paladin spell can only be cast on melee weapons, though. You'd have to get the GM to let you have a variant that worked on bows (if there isn't already one in one of the books).
The standard holy avenger magic item is specified as a longsword, but you could ask your GM for a variant.
The holy sword paladin spell can only be cast on melee weapons, though. You'd have to get the GM to let you have a variant that worked on bows (if there isn't already one in one of the books).
The standard holy avenger magic item is specified as a longsword, but you could ask your GM for a variant.
I would tend to think that the choice of weapon would be cultural. The association of swords (shaped like a cross, no less) in medieval European folklore make it the ideal choice for a Paladin based on these sources. Other cultural influences in a fantasy world could lead to other weapons.
I'd see a Paladin of Odin using a Holy Spear as a very reasonable example.
I'd see a Paladin of Odin using a Holy Spear as a very reasonable example.
(un)reason
Legend
Anything but holy whips. 
That just invokes images that are rather out of place for most paladins. Sure you might want to use it for your own penitence, but in actual battle it's a bit too slow a method of fighting.
That just invokes images that are rather out of place for most paladins. Sure you might want to use it for your own penitence, but in actual battle it's a bit too slow a method of fighting.
Doug McCrae
Legend
[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZDJaBHxt-E0"]Krull - The Glaive[/ame]
Go to 1min 50secs onwards for a good view of the weapon.
Last edited:
Aus_Snow
First Post
Well, good ol' Arthur had a spear, didn't he? And a dagger, and shield for good measure. . . but yeah, I could see spears being just fine.
Plus, they were just an extremely widely used weapon throughout much of history across the world. No reason to exclude them, I would think.
Axes, hammers, maces. . . hell, why not any given thing. That would be my take on the matter.
Plus, they were just an extremely widely used weapon throughout much of history across the world. No reason to exclude them, I would think.
Axes, hammers, maces. . . hell, why not any given thing. That would be my take on the matter.
I always try and tie it back to thier god/s, if you are going to do a god's work better do it with his weapon of choice.
Anything but holy whips.
Castlevania disagrees with you
I'm fine with paladins having whatever as their holy weapon. Just explain why and you're golden.
Similar Threads
