Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="starwed" data-source="post: 3036148" data-attributes="member: 36983">It's kind of silly to castigate a DM for house ruling one way, just because you would house rule another.  Perhaps there are official rules for "nondimensional" spaces that I'm unaware of, but you seem to be basing quite a lot off the flavor of the name.Again, I don't understand this.  There are no rules covering this situation.  It's not even clear that the bag of holding exists in another dimension.  (Even using real world physics, a space larger on the inside than the outside could exist.)  Rope trick might provide a cue to ruling one way or the other, but it certainly isn't equivalent to a general rule.  In other words, the DM gets to decide.The one unfair part is the giant not realising what he's pulling out of the bag.  That one I'd argue about quite a bit, because it defies common sense that you wouldn't notice what you're putting your hand on.  Where the rules are silent on "real world" issues, it's unfair to rule against common expectations.  (Like being able to feel what you touch.)</blockquote>