Stargate Atlantis vs Battlestar Galactica

[Olgar Shiverstone]

No desire here to jump into SGA since I never was particularly exicted by the original Stargate. Plus SGA is on against a show both my wife and I like: Third Watch.

I'm enjoying BSG thus far, though I have to admit I'd like a break from some of the psychologically-intense character-driven episodes, and have an episode where they launch Vipers and smoke some Cylon butt.

 

[cignus_pfaccari]

I like all three, SG1, SGA, and BSG.

BSG gets a bit more love because it's shiny and new, and because I expected it to suck horrendously and was pleasantly surprised. But I still like the Stargate series, especially when they do little crossover details (like, say, the

Spoiler

time-traveling puddlejumper

).

Brad

 

[LightPhoenix]

I like both equally, for different reasons. That said, someone asked me for a top-five list of currently running shows. BSG was in it, SGA wasn't.

Also, the second half of Jeremiah's second season blew major chunks.