D&D 5E Survivor Adventure Paths- TOA ANNIHILATES THE OPPOSITION!

[Ed Laprade]

Curse of Strahd 12 -2 = 10.
Hoard of the Dragon Queen 10
Out of the Abyss 14
Princes of the Apocalypse 20
Rise of Tiamat 19
Storm King's Thunder 14
Tales from the Yawning Portal 24 +1 = 25.
Tomb of Annihilation 18

 

[Harzel]

Correction for the downvote that wasn't...

Curse of Strahd 17
Hoard of the Dragon Queen 15
Out of the Abyss 16
Princes of the Apocalypse 22 - After ToD, my EK Half-Orc Umsh and our Dwarven Vengenge Paladin teamed up to take on the Princes (the rest of the ToD group couldn't continue) and had an absolute blast playing 15th level characters in the AP.
Rise of Tiamat 19
Storm King's Thunder 16
Tales from the Yawning Portal 19
Tomb of Annihilation 17 - Downvoting because we haven't had time to play this yet. Dang it WoTC for putting out more content than we have time for!

Curse of Strahd 18 - if you're going to be derivative, derive from something good.
Hoard of the Dragon Queen 15 - not the worst module ever made (there are so many contenders for that title from the 80s - Forest Oracle, Crystal Princess, etc, etc...), but the worst 5e AP so far, by far.
Out of the Abyss 16
Princes of the Apocalypse 22
Rise of Tiamat 19
Storm King's Thunder 16
Tales from the Yawning Portal 19
Tomb of Annihilation 17

Curse of Strahd 10
Hoard of the Dragon Queen 8
Out of the Abyss 14
Princes of the Apocalypse 20
Rise of Tiamat 19
Storm King's Thunder 14
Tales from the Yawning Portal 25
Tomb of Annihilation 18

 

[Tony Vargas]

Curse of Strahd 11
Hoard of the Dragon Queen 6
Out of the Abyss 14
Princes of the Apocalypse 20
Rise of Tiamat 19
Storm King's Thunder 14
Tales from the Yawning Portal 25
Tomb of Annihilation 18

 

[rgoodbb]

Curse of Strahd 12
Hoard of the Dragon Queen 6
Out of the Abyss 12
Princes of the Apocalypse 20
Rise of Tiamat 19
Storm King's Thunder 14
Tales from the Yawning Portal 25
Tomb of Annihilation 18

 

[Yardiff]

Curse of Strahd 12-2=10
Hoard of the Dragon Queen 6
Out of the Abyss 12
Princes of the Apocalypse 20
Rise of Tiamat 19
Storm King's Thunder 14
Tales from the Yawning Portal 25+1=26
Tomb of Annihilation 18

 

[Icarus Dreams]

Curse of Strahd 10
Hoard of the Dragon Queen 6-2=4
Out of the Abyss 12
Princes of the Apocalypse 20
Rise of Tiamat 19
Storm King's Thunder 14
Tales from the Yawning Portal 26
Tomb of Annihilation 18+1=19

HotDQ just read like a hot mess. ToA got me genuinely excited for an adventure path for the first time. Plus, it's an example of exploration-based adventure design, which I felt was lacking in previous APs.

 

[Schmoe]

Curse of Strahd 10
Hoard of the Dragon Queen 4
Out of the Abyss 12
Princes of the Apocalypse 20+1=21
Rise of Tiamat 19
Storm King's Thunder 14
Tales from the Yawning Portal 26-2=24
Tomb of Annihilation 19

 

[SuperTD]

Curse of Strahd 10
Hoard of the Dragon Queen 4
Out of the Abyss 12
Princes of the Apocalypse 22 As the only path I have run to completion, this has to get my vote despite it's flaws and the fact that I would probably enjoy running Strahd or Tomb more, and think they are better written.
Rise of Tiamat 19
Storm King's Thunder 14 Although there are some cool locations and dungeons, I dislike that the story is set up to have you ignore half the book's contents and I'm not a fan of giving characters super buffs just to have them fight a bigger enemy at a lower level.
Tales from the Yawning Portal 24
Tomb of Annihilation 19

 

[OB1]

Curse of Strahd 11 - Third session coming up this long weekend
Hoard of the Dragon Queen 4
Out of the Abyss 12
Princes of the Apocalypse 22
Rise of Tiamat 19
Storm King's Thunder 12 - Another one we just haven't had time to play yet
Tales from the Yawning Portal 24
Tomb of Annihilation 19

 

[Eltab]

Curse of Strahd 11
Hoard of the Dragon Queen 4 - 2 = 2 However the Fifth Anniversary Reprint (which fixes all the rules errors) would be worth up-voting. Caravan chapter FTW !
Out of the Abyss 12
Princes of the Apocalypse 22 + 1 = 23 Played part-way through and think it is an excellent plot for PCs who want to 'build up' an area
Rise of Tiamat 19
Storm King's Thunder 12
Tales from the Yawning Portal 24
Tomb of Annihilation 19