Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Sunglare" data-source="post: 4685889" data-attributes="member: 61180">So....1. Wizard cast Freezing cloud2.&nbsp; There are creatures in Freezing Cloud3. Some creatures move to surrond Wizard4. It's the start of the creatures turn in the Freezing Cloud5. Wizard rolls to hit creatures in cloud. 6. Creatures around wizard get to make Opprotunity Attacks on Wizard&nbsp;???????????Seems pretty messed up to me but if you apply the the logic that the sustain action follows the same descriptor of the initial attack (melee, range, close, area) then it would apply to this wizard situation too. Seems best that unless a Sustain action actually says to make another range or area attack it does not cause an opprotunity attack. &nbsp;Summons of Khirad&nbsp; initial attack says &quot;Standard Action Ranged 10.&quot;but the Sustain only says &quot;Sustain minor&quot; and does not say &quot;Sustain minor range 10.&quot;&nbsp;Another question we can ask ourselves when analyzing if the sustain is considered a ranged attack is is it limited to the range of the inital attack too? If one was to argue that the sustain is considered range because the initial attack is then one can not sustain the power if they go beyond the range of the initial attack.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Sunglare, post: 4685889, member: 61180"] So.... 1. Wizard cast Freezing cloud 2. There are creatures in Freezing Cloud 3. Some creatures move to surrond Wizard 4. It's the start of the creatures turn in the Freezing Cloud 5. Wizard rolls to hit creatures in cloud. 6. Creatures around wizard get to make Opprotunity Attacks on Wizard ??????????? Seems pretty messed up to me but if you apply the the logic that the sustain action follows the same descriptor of the initial attack (melee, range, close, area) then it would apply to this wizard situation too. Seems best that unless a Sustain action actually says to make another range or area attack it does not cause an opprotunity attack. [B]Summons of Khirad[/B] initial attack says "Standard Action Ranged 10." but the Sustain only says "Sustain minor" and [B]does not[/B] say "Sustain minor range 10." Another question we can ask ourselves when analyzing if the sustain is considered a ranged attack is is it limited to the range of the inital attack too? If one was to argue that the sustain is considered range because the initial attack is then one can not sustain the power if they go beyond the range of the initial attack. [/QUOTE]

Verification