The Leading Ladies Showdown Round 4

[MonsterMash]

1. Buffy: The Chosen One (tv)
2. Catwoman (Batman)
3. Eowyn (Lord of the Rings)
4. Lt. Ellen Ripley ("Alien" movies)

 

[kitoy]

1. Wonder Woman
2. Princess Leia Organa nee Skywalker
3. Mulan, savior of all of China
4. Lt. Ellen Ripley

 

[MonsterMash]

**sputter**

Emma Peel's GONE?!?

**sigh** hardly even worth continuing...

1. Buffy [marginally better -- nearly a pass]
2. Catwoman
3. Eowyn
4. Ripley [certainly better than Supergirl, but...]

Probably won't vote next round...

A Travesty and I just hope that the sensible choices prevail next round.

 

[Tonguez]

Emma Peel's GONE?!?

Emma Peel was too good for this competiton anyway

She is in a league of her own

 

[Acid_crash]

1. Wonder Woman (comics, tv) vs. Buffy: The Chosen One (tv)
2. Catwoman (Batman) vs. Princess Leia Organa nee Skywalker (Star Wars)
3. Mulan, savior of all of China vs. Eowyn (Lord of the Rings)
4. Lt. Ellen Ripley ("Alien" movies) vs. Supergirl (comics, movies, tv)

1. Wonder Woman
2. Catwoman
3. Mulan
4. Supergirl

 

[Klaus]

1. Wonder Woman (comics, tv)

As much as I like Buffy, Wonder Woman is *THE* original female superhero. And George Pérez's origin for her is way too mythic to ignore.

2. Princess Leia Organa nee Skywalker (Star Wars)

She takes c**p from no one, she gets tortured and reveals nothing, she looked Tarkin in the eye and didn't flinch and when her beau was taken by bounty hunters, she went underground as a bounty hunter with nary a second thought. Plus, gold bikinis rule!

3. Mulan, savior of all of China

Fa Mulan is the iconic hero of over one billion people. Sorry, Eowyn.

4. Lt. Ellen Ripley ("Alien" movies)

Supergirl suffers from too many interpretations in this, specially the latest lame attempt, which totally ignores the existense of Matrix/Linda Danvers.

 

[jasper]

1. Wonder Woman
2. Catwoman
3. Eowyn
4. Supergirl.

Sorry I have to disagree with Stevelaby. If the list is not random then the run of list can force a win or lost. The best list is to scamble all the names first and do that match up. Then top half fights bottom half.

 

[Storm Raven]

1. Wonder Woman
2. Princess Leia Organa
3. Eowyn
4. Lt. Ellen Ripley

 

[Aris Dragonborn]

1. Wonder Woman (comics, tv)
2. Princess Leia Organa nee Skywalker (Star Wars)
3. Eowyn (Lord of the Rings)
4. Supergirl (comics, movies, tv)

 

[Endur]

errr, the brackets are ranked, almost.

We've been doing 1-32 vs. 33 vs. 64
A truly ranked system would be 1-32 vs. 64-33
I would have set it up that way if I had been the original organizer, but I was just following in what the previous system had been.

the guys running all these contests really needed to set up ranked brackets as opposed to randomness. These two should be fighting in the final not the quarterfinals.