Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Jhamin" data-source="post: 1264533" data-attributes="member: 1023">See, to me that just came off as lazy and overblown.  We were supposed to be horrified at the awful decisions our good-hearted characters were forced to make.  It was so over the top that it was almost funny.My girlfriend wondered aloud of the producers couldn't find a basket of kittens for her to play with just before the nukes dropped.  Maybe a Nun could have thrown her body in front to the blast?It was just weak.From my point of view, the writers had three characters make live/die decisions for others in part two, and two of the three were immediatly undercut.*Depressurize the burning part of Galactica - Pretty harsh, but the right thing to do.*Leave the non-ftl civilian ships to their fate, don't wait for them to x-fer passangers.  Oh wait, they got blown up before we could even leave.  I guess we don't have to wonder if we made the right decision.*Pick a random guy to frame as a Cylon so I can cover my but while pointing out the cylon thingie (which was never mentioned again).  How big a jerk am I for selling out an innocent?  Oh wait, I guess he really *was* a Cylon so it all worked out.  (OK, so it was Baltar.  But now he has unknowing done a good thing for the wrong reason.  IF you want him flawed, let him be.)</blockquote>