The Shining South

Samurai

Adventurer
I've seen a lot of talk about Libris Mortis, but no mention yet of Shining South. Was I the only one to pick up this book? ;)

I think the PrCs are very flavorful and interesting, with strong motivations and adventure hooks with them. The Magehound is tasked with policing rogue mages and magic, for instance, and that could be a very interesting theme for a camapign. The Jordain Vizier is the Forgotten Realms version of Sherlock Holmes, with the ability to notice tiny details and make deductions from them. The Marchwarden is a specialist at protecting a given area of land, creating a more static campaign where the PCs protect a town, a druid grove, etc, and trouble comes to them.

If I have 1 complaint about the book, it's the bulging random encounter charts. Though not as bad as Frostburn's 25 pages, Shining South does devote 11-12 pages to them, twice as much as Unapproachable East and 3x as much as Underdark did. PLEASE, if WotC writers read this, keep random encounter charts to a minimum (4-5 pages max). I know of very few DMs who use them (I don't), making them a waste of space to many of us that could be better filled with more creatures, added locale descriptions, heck, even some evocative artwork that stirs the imagination would be preferable, IMO.

Overall, a very nice book that maintains the quality established in previous FR books. Quite a few fun and interesting ideas within these pages!
 
Last edited:

log in or register to remove this ad


Hi,

I'm really looking forward to this -- more than Libris Mortis! I quite like random encounter tables in regional sourcebooks -- it gives me a list of what creatures can be found in a specific area.

There are maps, aren't there? Serpent Kingdoms was a good book, but would have been much better if regional maps had been included.

Cheers


Richard
 

I'm really looking forward to this. My first 3E campaign that ran to Epic levels was a modified Night Below that started in Dambrath, went to the Forest of Amtar and then, of course, into the Underdark. This product should provide me with some motivation to revisit the area in another campaign.

I'm also really delighted to see that we now have two Crabapple-free products in a row. It seems like WotC now actually has some standards for their art....

As for the wandering monster tables: agreed, too many pages have been used. I would prefer these things to be web enhancements or simply not done at all.
 

Zamora said:
Hi,

I'm really looking forward to this -- more than Libris Mortis! I quite like random encounter tables in regional sourcebooks -- it gives me a list of what creatures can be found in a specific area.

There are maps, aren't there? Serpent Kingdoms was a good book, but would have been much better if regional maps had been included.

Cheers


Richard
Yes, I believe there are 6 full page maps and 3 smaller, 1/2 page city maps, plus the encounter areas in the back of the book. It's comparable to Unapproachable East in that regard.
 

Sammael said:
Is there an entire chapter on the Shaar? Can you post the ToC?
I can't take the time to type up the full ToC, but yes, there is an entire chapter on the Shaar... 20 pages, including 2 large maps.

If you have any other FR books, you know the layout/contents of this one... new races, feats, 33 new spells, 9 PrCs, magic items, and 11 monsters. A section on campaigning in the area, including encounter tables. Then a chapter for each major area (~20 pages each), followed by a few adventure sites. It covers the Shaar and the Great Rift, Halruaa, Dambrath, Luiren, Estagund and the Shining Lands.
 



Samurai said:
It covers the Shaar and the Great Rift, Halruaa, Dambrath, Luiren, Estagund and the Shining Lands.

Where there is overlap with Serpent Kingdoms, are the SK locations marked on the maps?

Cheers


Richard
 


Remove ads

Top