Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Charlaquin" data-source="post: 9589788" data-attributes="member: 6779196">I’m not working hard to make it difficult, I am pointing out what the text literally says.Correct, and neither of those sets of conditions include an enemy having line of sight to you. Which is obviously not the intent, since hiding behind a tree should not continue to make you impossible to see once you are no longer hidden behind the tree. This is a flaw in the writing that produces an obviously unintended result.And where in the hide action does it say an enemy finds you if it gains line of sight to you?And where in the invisibility spell does it say that an enemy does not find you if it gains line of sight to you?Right, and neither does it say anything about whether and when an enemy can see you while under the condition (without losing it), though its text does imply that’s a possibility. So we must look to the different sources of the condition to determine these things. And neither the invisibility spell nor the hide action provide that clarity.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Charlaquin, post: 9589788, member: 6779196"] I’m not working hard to make it difficult, I am pointing out what the text literally says. Correct, and neither of those sets of conditions include an enemy having line of sight to you. Which is obviously not the intent, since hiding behind a tree should not continue to make you impossible to see once you are no longer hidden behind the tree. This is a flaw in the writing that produces an obviously unintended result. And where in the hide action does it say an enemy finds you if it gains line of sight to you? And where in the invisibility spell does it say that an enemy does not find you if it gains line of sight to you? Right, and neither does it say anything about whether and when an enemy can see you while under the condition (without losing it), though its text does imply that’s a possibility. So we must look to the different sources of the condition to determine these things. And neither the invisibility spell nor the hide action provide that clarity. [/QUOTE]

Verification