Don't sweat it, gang. We're going to consider it for a day or so and then make a call. I think at the least, the community supporter tags will disappear; as Turanil said, custom titles do a great job of identifying them already.
I'm inclined to agree with this. Perhaps down below the avatar, just above the "Join Date" would be a less obtrusive place? I also think the colors are a little jarring, they don't really mesh well with the page style (aside from Tech Admin, which is on dark grey).
I like the moderator and admin medallions since they lost their glow. I'm fine with just the custom title for community supporters. Thanks for the work and looking for ways to make the site even better.
I like the idea of a small flag or other symbol to represent Community Supporters. I also like the idea that the user can customize this to make it disappear if they so choose.
I too have to chime in and say I like them, and agree placement might be better below.
Option to display them or not would be great as well so that choice is maintained by the end user.