Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Oofta" data-source="post: 8614294" data-attributes="member: 6801845">Another thought on this is that it simply doesn't work.  Why?  Because a wish can be used to replicate a spell of 8th level or lower and what the PC is asking for is a True Polymorph spell.  That is a 9th level spell.  It's also limited to CR equal to or less than the target.  While PC levels don't directly correlate to CR, a 10th level monk is not a CR 13 creature.So I would rule that wish cannot do something that a 9th level spell that specifically addresses what the wish is attempting cannot.  True Polymorph allows the target to retain their alignment, personality and abilities (if the new form allows them). Using a wish?  A vampire pops in and instantly kills the target.  Congratulations, you are now a vampire spawn under the control of your master.</blockquote>