D&D 5E Two Quick Questions

Motorskills

Explorer
1) The WOTC forum had a great Q&A thread...is there such for EN World?

2) In lieu of that, please can some kind person confirm if Silence can be cast on an object and moved around?
 

log in or register to remove this ad



Away from book, but 95% sure that is not correct. IIRC you can cast it on an item, or a willing target, and have the effect move with the item/person.
You either can't cast it on a bad guy, or they get a save.... think the former.
 

In 5e, silence is cast on a point you choose within range. There is no mention of it moving, or being cast on an object or creature. It creates a zone that does not move.

An extremely liberal interpretation of the spell could allow that the point chosen is an object and that it can subsequently be moved, but this is contrary to rules-as-intended. Note that pretty much every other "area effect" spell uses exactly the same terminology. You cast a fireball at a point you choose. You cast an earthquake on a point on the ground. Nobody is going to allow that you can cast an earthquake on a stone on the ground, and then pick up the stone and move the area of effect (...although, having said that, that'd be pretty cool). The same is true for cloud of daggers, confusion, and many other spells. All use the phrasing "at a point you choose within range". If they can be cast on a single creature or object and then move with that object, it'd create a balance nightmare.

So, no. In 5e, a silence spell does not move.
 
Last edited:

I agree, silence is cast on a point and not an object. If a spell can be cast on an object it gets obvious from the spell description, e.g. see the light spell.

PS: I wouldn't mind if we had a "Ask quick question, get quick answer" thread here. So far I've just been creating a new thread for every question, but those threads disappear very fast as there are so many created here every day.
 

Remove ads

Top