Villains - The Evil Within
Review by William L. Collins
This is an M&M Superlink book containing 10 villains. The author is Bob Bretz. This 25-page pdf comes from The Le Games. Three of the pages are the OGL – which in my opinion could have been compressed to a smaller size for publication. The art is a mix of clip art from Louis Porter and black and white drawings by Tony Perna. The product retails for $2.25 on RPGnow.com. I received a free copy for review purposes, as part of Crothian’s Review Project. The publisher provides a full-color “screen” version and a black and white printer-friendly copy as part of the 3.5 Meg download.
Ten villains get profiled for this volume: Atomico, Black Dragon, Chill-Kill, Daemon, Doctor Mon-Star, Night Wolf, Obsidian Ghost, Silverlok, Steel Titan, and Thrasher. All the villains are dual-statted for PL-15 and PL-20. Since I never play at PL-20, this volume isn’t as useful to me as it would be if it were dual-statted for PL-10 and PL-15, but it’s still a good source of villains if you need one fast.
Out of these ten, the standouts are Atomico, Doctor Mon-Star and Silverlok. They all have something interesting about them – Atomico is a former hero teleported into the future and given a radiation accident. Doctor Mon-Star tries to bring silver screen monsters to life (hey, is he really Ray Harryhausen?). Silverlok learned how to project her mind into computers for the US Air Force and to control some Psycho Spheres.
Unfortunately, the background on these villains is fairly short. We get a paragraph or two on each one’s origin, but few other details. Too many of the villains had the Disturbing weakness. (Weaknesses are not the be all and end all like Disadvantages are in Champions, but a little more variation would be good.) Many of these are riffs on common superhero/villain concepts (Obsidian Ghost for example seems a lot like Eclipso, right down to the mysterious gem that gives him powers). There are no new powers or abilities in this volume; there are also no questionable Flaws applied to the powers. It’s all by the book, which means you don’t have to double-check or reread a lot.
The good news is that these villains are fairly optimized and not weak. You can slot them in and they’ll give PCs a run for their money
The illustrations are okay, but I wonder if they wouldn’t have looked better as black and white? (That’s the problem with four-color superheroes – everyone’s a critic.) Objectively though, they definitely beat some of the art in Champions First, Second and Third Editions, so that’s a positive. However, the advent of 3E meant art standards rose, so I would have liked a more consistent art style, especially for a comic book-inspired medium.
This is a 2005 release. It doesn’t state if it’s for First or Second Edition M&M, so it’s probably First Edition. It should be compatible with either though. I found a few typos and editing errors, which definitely brought down the rating. With nothing strikingly new or interesting, but some utility, I give this product a 3 because of its utility. If you need a bunch of new villains for your game tonight, and are strapped for time, the price makes the download reasonable.