we have to remember that this goldfish is 8 inches long. I would hesitate to get rid of such a large, unflushable, ancient fish. So, i guess the question to ask isn't, "are you willing to spend 2 bucks on a new goldfish?" but rather, "are you willing to spend 17 years of your life keeping such a fish alive (which is admittedly harder than it appears, just ask my brother who went through Knuckles I through Knuckles III, and has since deemed the name unlucky) until it is just as big." Oh well, i wonder what it tastes like, fillet of goldfish, yummm.....