Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="AaronOfBarbaria" data-source="post: 6827114" data-attributes="member: 6701872">I doesn't seem to me like a case of the player not remembering actually being the thing that resulted in the problem.The DM knew the player had 3 items in a bundle.The Player knew they were selling a suit of armor, and said as much.The DM then thought that it seemed like the player had forgotten about the ring and gauntlets, and instead of giving the player the benefit of the doubt and having the character present only the armor to the blacksmith chose the &quot;you didn't say you weren't also doing these other things, so you did them&quot; route and even stuck to it once the players made it clear that they had considered the armor completely separate from the gauntlets and ring by way of their not stepping in while the other player sold them, and by assuming they still had them to be identified like they said was their next goal.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="AaronOfBarbaria, post: 6827114, member: 6701872"] I doesn't seem to me like a case of the player not remembering actually being the thing that resulted in the problem. The DM knew the player had 3 items in a bundle. The Player knew they were selling a suit of armor, and said as much. The DM then thought that it seemed like the player had forgotten about the ring and gauntlets, and instead of giving the player the benefit of the doubt and having the character present only the armor to the blacksmith chose the "you didn't [I]say[/I] you weren't also doing these other things, so you did them" route and even stuck to it once the players made it clear that they had considered the armor completely separate from the gauntlets and ring by way of their not stepping in while the other player sold them, and by assuming they still had them to be identified like they said was their next goal. [/QUOTE]

Verification