Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="delericho" data-source="post: 6811007" data-attributes="member: 22424">In general, my list of things 5e got wrong has very little to do with the game, and is more about things that are around the game. Fortunately some, though not all, of these have been fixed by the community.For example:- The index has already been mentioned, as has the community generated version. (And yes, I know 5e actually compares well with other RPGs in terms of an index. But that's no credit to 5e - it's a mark of how badly other games do in this area.)- The official character sheet is very poor. Again, the community have rectified this.- I've found the Monster Creation rules to be extremely poorly explained. Here, again, Angry DM did a series of articles that totally turn them around, and make them very useful, but I do wish they'd written them differently (that is, better) in the first place.But my big, #1 complaint:- The bindings of the Core Rulebooks are simply not good enough for a $50 book. My DMG had pages coming loose before I completed even a read-through of the book, with no at-table use whatsoever. Given that I have a 1st Ed &quot;Unearthed Arcana&quot; with a solid binding (despite that book being notorious for the same), this really isn't good enough.Don't get me wrong, WotC have created a great game, but there's just a few things that really grate.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="delericho, post: 6811007, member: 22424"] In general, my list of things 5e got wrong has very little to do with [i]the game[/i], and is more about things that are around the game. Fortunately some, though not all, of these have been fixed by the community. For example: - The index has already been mentioned, as has the community generated version. (And yes, I know 5e actually compares well with other RPGs in terms of an index. But that's no credit to 5e - it's a mark of how badly other games do in this area.) - The official character sheet is very poor. Again, the community have rectified this. - I've found the Monster Creation rules to be extremely poorly explained. Here, again, Angry DM did a series of articles that totally turn them around, and make them very useful, but I do wish they'd written them differently (that is, better) in the first place. But my big, #1 complaint: - The bindings of the Core Rulebooks are simply not good enough for a $50 book. My DMG had pages coming loose before I completed even a read-through of the book, with no at-table use whatsoever. Given that I have a 1st Ed "Unearthed Arcana" with a solid binding (despite that book being notorious for the same), this really isn't good enough. Don't get me wrong, WotC have created a great game, but there's just a few things that [i]really[/i] grate. [/QUOTE]

Verification