Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Wystan" data-source="post: 4023148" data-attributes="member: 21422">If most Crafters who were Really good -&nbsp; - only succeeded about 50% of the time, we would have a REALLY expensive society as a 50% failure rate would drive most people to stop even trying (and remember you stated that this is the Really good ones....)I personally think that a Trained Crafter who is maxed in his ranks should succeed at appropriate tasks 90% of the time or more, and less as the training becomes less complete and or the task becomes more complex/difficult.Example: Swordsmith creating a Longsword - &nbsp;&nbsp; 1. Max Trained Swordsmith (skill about 10 total) should only fail making a longsword 1-2% of the time. &nbsp;&nbsp; 2. Apprentice Swordsmith (Skill about 5 total) should fail making a longsword 20-30% of the time&nbsp;&nbsp; 3. Joe Untrained Swordsmith (Skill 0-1 total) should fail 90% of the time.Swordsmith Creating a Quicksilver Longsword - &nbsp;&nbsp; 1. Max Trained Swordsmith (skill about 10 total) should only fail making a Quicksilver longsword 10% of the time. &nbsp;&nbsp; 2. Apprentice Swordsmith (Skill about 5 total) should fail making a Quicksilver longsword 40-50% of the time&nbsp;&nbsp; 3. Joe Untrained Swordsmith (Skill 0-1 total) should fail 99.999% of the time.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Wystan, post: 4023148, member: 21422"] If most Crafters who were Really good - - only succeeded about 50% of the time, we would have a REALLY expensive society as a 50% failure rate would drive most people to stop even trying (and remember you stated that this is the Really good ones....) I personally think that a Trained Crafter who is maxed in his ranks should succeed at appropriate tasks 90% of the time or more, and less as the training becomes less complete and or the task becomes more complex/difficult. Example: Swordsmith creating a Longsword - 1. Max Trained Swordsmith (skill about 10 total) should only fail making a longsword 1-2% of the time. 2. Apprentice Swordsmith (Skill about 5 total) should fail making a longsword 20-30% of the time 3. Joe Untrained Swordsmith (Skill 0-1 total) should fail 90% of the time. Swordsmith Creating a Quicksilver Longsword - 1. Max Trained Swordsmith (skill about 10 total) should only fail making a Quicksilver longsword 10% of the time. 2. Apprentice Swordsmith (Skill about 5 total) should fail making a Quicksilver longsword 40-50% of the time 3. Joe Untrained Swordsmith (Skill 0-1 total) should fail 99.999% of the time. [/QUOTE]

Verification