Rya.Reisender
Explorer
My players just don't manage to discuss strategies in character.
So still describing firebolt in fantasticle graphic technicolour detail then?
Quite often for us. We do like to role play, but we're never so serious about it that we can't also be ourselves with each other while we play. This is a group of all friends, not just people who are together only to play D&D, so that may play into it.
I prefer to roleplay in real life, and only be myself when I'm playing D&D.
Roleplaying level? It's over 9000!
Seriously, I love my group. Everyone has strong personalities and motivations. Dialog word choices and vocabulary would immediately tell you what character was talking if it was just transcribed, and for the ones that do it also an accent/way of speaking. Personalities are full-fledged, with flaws as well. We give out little "good RP" bennies and players who have missed the session sometimes still get them because they have such a strong personality that someone chimes in how they would respond to something and we all nod knowingly. We "pose" during combat, describing the attack and effects, and character personality affects tactics. We often do sessions without combat, occasionally with minimal dice roll of any type. We had a memorable session that ended up being nothing but great intra-party RP over a night of watches. Not at all what I had planned for the session but it was great.
As a DM I try to keep up with them and stay in that mode myself.
Okay, we occasionally drop out for rules questions, or to make a geek-joke. But we really stay in character.