Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Thomas Shey" data-source="post: 9131371" data-attributes="member: 7026617">Given I made the latter qualification in part of that statement in virtually the first part of my criticism there (where I mentioned AMP:Y)), if you're going to get snarky about it, take it up with whoever you're arguing with in your head, not me. Do you somehow think I'm going to agree with this more the second time you go around with me on it?&nbsp; Is something supposed to have changed?Edit: To make this abundantly clear, I'm talking about general-purpose superhero games here; I'll accept theoretically that a class and level (though the latter part is a harder sell) system might be appropriate for some special purpose (i.e. setting specific) superhero or superhero adjacent games.&nbsp; That said, it'd have to be very specific; just being low powered or narrow is not going to help, per se; it requires that the setting has reasons for types to be strongly bucketed that is not normal or superhero settings in general.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Thomas Shey, post: 9131371, member: 7026617"] Given I made the latter qualification in part of that statement in virtually the first part of my criticism there (where I mentioned AMP:Y)), if you're going to get snarky about it, take it up with whoever you're arguing with in your head, not me. Do you somehow think I'm going to agree with this more the second time you go around with me on it? Is something supposed to have changed? Edit: To make this abundantly clear, I'm talking about general-purpose superhero games here; I'll accept theoretically that a class and level (though the latter part is a harder sell) system might be appropriate for some special purpose (i.e. setting specific) superhero or superhero adjacent games. That said, it'd have to be very specific; just being low powered or narrow is not going to help, per se; it requires that the setting has reasons for types to be strongly bucketed that is not normal or superhero settings in general. [/QUOTE]

Verification