D&D 2E Which 2e campaign setting should make a comeback in 4e?

[Gundark]

Yeah I'd like to see Realm management rules for 4e. While they existed for 3e, I felt alot of products fell short. Fields of Blood came close...but where more competitive in nature (competing with other players).

Dark Sun while a unique setting, is just D&D with different cloths. Birthright you actually did something different from the standard D&D.

 

[Stormborn]

While I would love to see Spelljammer or Darksun I think realistically I, and most games, would be best served by OA and Al-Quadim as they can represent other cultures and areas on an established game world.

 

[AffableVagrant]

I'd actively like to see Spelljammer and Dark Sun updated. However, I'd like the updates to come in the form of:

1. A single hardcover (OK, I would like a softcover because that's what I prefer, but that's not gonna happen ) providing the basics of the setting, some key monsters, any new classes or races, and any other signature crunch (like the ship rules for Spelljammer).

2. Support in Dungeon and Dragon via the Digital Initiative.

3. Monsters updated in the generic monster manuals.

The Dungeon/Dragon magazine support seems critical to me. All of those settings are pretty cool, but if WoC is going to do it, they should really do it all the way and release plenty of content via DDI.

As a side note, I think revisions of these settings for 4e might appeal to the oldschool gamers out there who are skeptical of new editions... so long as the designers remain true to the spirit of the original games.

 

[olshanski]

What happened to Hollow Earth Campaign Setting?
Maztica? (Was that only a subset of FR? or a campaign setting in its own right?)
Savage Coast?
Council of Wyrms?
Jakandor?

 

[Cadriel]

I voted Dark Sun. I'm not really that interested in 4th edition, but I'd love to see the setting get a serious, thorough treatment again that I could adapt to another system (probably some kind of C&C/2e hybrid).

- Wayne

 

[Cadriel]

What happened to Hollow Earth Campaign Setting?

Hollow Earth is a part of Mystara.

Maztica? (Was that only a subset of FR? or a campaign setting in its own right?)

FR sub-setting.

Savage Coast?

Mystara again.

Council of Wyrms?

Sort of a "drop-in" for other settings.

Jakandor?

Pretty explicitly a drop-in setting.

 

[Howndawg]

Dark Sun for me. Although I'd probably check out most of the others.

Howndawg

 

[GoodKingJayIII]

Birthright, homies. But my second choice is Dark Sun.

 

[Angel Tarragon]

Planescape coming up on the inside.

 

[Dark Psion]

None of the above

I don't want to see what is being done the Forgotten Realms done to any other setting.