Which of the following 3PP v.3.5 products should I buy?

[Knightfall]

Okay, since I consider my d20 Modern poll thread to be a success, I figured I'd create one for v.3.5 material from 3PPs. I already have a lot of 3PP v.3.5 products from such companies as Goodman, Green Ronin, Fantasy Flight, Paizo, Necromancer, and Malhavoc, so unless a 3PP from one of those companies is actually listed on the poll then don't worry about suggesting it.

I'm not interested in buying any more WotC v.3.5 products as I have all of those I'll ever need. I'm only looking to add the "best of best" to my extensive library of v.3.5 products. Note that I'm not into buying PDFs but if you have to suggest a PDF then make it a good one. Regardless, I prefer physical books. If a PDF is available as a Print on Demand product (from someplace like Lulu.com) then I'd be interested in hearing about it.

Note: You only get to select one option for the poll.

Cheers!

KF72

 

[Rechan]

Book of Erotic Fantasy

This is a serious option in the poll?

 

[DaveMage]

I voted Ptolus, but Wilderlands of High Fantasy Box Set is right there with it.

There are also a few other gems on there, such as Arms & Armor v3.5, which is very cool.

 

[Frost]

I voted for Eldritch Sorcery. It seems to be a vastly under-rated book. It was a tough choice, though, there are a lot of good books up there (not sure about the Book of EF, though).

 

[Crothian]

All of them

 

[Psion]

Note: You only get to select one option for the poll.

I refuse! I'll post instead!

These are staples AFAIAC...
Arms & Armor v.3.5
Book of the Righteous
Eldritch Sorcery
Grim Tales
Ptolus: Monte Cook's City by the Spire
Slavelords of Cydonia
The Black Company Campaign Setting
Wilderlands of High Fantasy

 

[Wombat]

Go for The Book of the Righteous -- the set of gods is amazing and quite portable between settings; you can pick and choose parts of it; there are great classes; lots of material that you can sift through that can be used in toto in or pieces -- a great bargain!

 

[haaz]

I have voted Tome of Horrors III. But the II is great too (those two books are perhaps the best 3pp monster books imho), and Eldricht Sorcery is great. Look also at The book of * Might, from Malhavoc Press (either Eldricht, Hallowed or Iron (really a great book)).

 

[avin]

TOHIII all the way.

 

[timbannock]

I voted for Lost City of Barakus...of all the 3PP books, I've used that the most. Two campaigns, in fact.

I also like Chaositech from that list.

3PP books I've enjoyed the most (whether or not I actually used them much so far): Rappan Athuk Reloaded, Tome of Horrors (Revised), City of Brass, World's Largest Dungeon, Pathfinder Vol 1-7, Castle Whiterock and what I've used of Castle Zagyg so far.

Honestly, I think my all-time favorite would be tied w/ Rappan Athuk and Castle Whiterock. These are just two great dungeon/sandbox settings.