Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="ColonelHardisson" data-source="post: 537726" data-attributes="member: 363">First, like I said, McKellan is Gandalf. I won't argue that. However, I knew of McKellan before LotR - most notably in Gods and Monsters - and like the best actors, he is able to submerge himself into the role to the point you see the character, not the actor. I think Stewart can also do that. What's problematic is that Trek fans, even casual ones, often can't get past the fact they're seeing Captain Picard. I know I've been like that. But remove that unique bit of pop cultural baggage, and you have a Shakespearean actor in Stewart that I feel could have played Gandalf quite well, to the point you would see Gandalf, not Picard - or Stewart. The reason I can't see Stewart playing Denethor is what makes him a good choice for Gandalf - Stewart has a natural warmth to him that makes him instantly likable. McKellan also has that quality. Denethor needs an actor that is less instantly likable, but at the same time instantly commands respect.When I heard Cate Blanchett was playing Galadriel, I thought it was perfect casting. I still do. I will say, though, that Michelle Pfeiffer would also have been a good choice.</blockquote>