Who would win in a fight?

[DreadPirateMurphy]

So, who would win in a fight and why? This is just for fun...

Superman

Strengths: Faster than a speeding bullet, more powerful than a locamotive, etc.

Weaknesses: Secret identity, overconfidence due to being so super, Achilles heel available to every villain with a credit card and an eBay account.

Elminster

Strengths: Loremaster, archmage, friends with benefits in high places.

Weaknesses: Vancian magic peculiarities, desire to avoid provoking archvillains, women, food and tobacco.

Neo

Strengths: Alter reality through force of will, knows kung fu, has access to guns...lots of guns.

Weaknesses: Slow on the uptake, messiah complex, Carrie-Anne Moss.

Luke Skywalker

Strengths: Force is strong with this one, lightsabre, pilot who can bullseye womp rats.

Weaknesses: Penchant for the dark side, faith in friends, daddy issues.

 

[crazy_monkey1956]

Elminster.

He can conjure up some Kryptonite. Bye bye supes.

Neo's powers only work within an artificial electronic construct. El doesn't need magic to just unplug him.

Luke is the only who would put up a decent fight and El has a large enough variety of spells to hold him off and subdue him.

 

[john112364]

Elminster.

He can conjure up some Kryptonite. Bye bye supes.

Neo's powers only work within an artificial electronic construct. El doesn't need magic to just unplug him.

Luke is the only who would put up a decent fight and El has a large enough variety of spells to hold him off and subdue him.

I agree for pretty much the same reasons.
Elminster works with magic which totally screws with Supes.
Neo need his computer world to do anything cool.
Luke just isn't as much of a bad ass as Elminster (though if he was fully trained as a Jedi, it would be a different story. That would be a rocking fight!)

 

[Klaus]

Superman. He zaps Elminster's spell component pouch with his heat vision before Elminster can blink.

 

[Crothian]

A lot depends on the set up and where they are. Does Elminster get a chance to prepare spells knowing his opponent? Are they starting 5 feet from each other or five miles?

I'm pretty sure this is going to be a complicate Rock/Paper/Scissors and dependant on who's writing the story

 

[Jdvn1]

Chuck Norris.