Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="BobTheNob" data-source="post: 5951712" data-attributes="member: 82425">I was very determined to not be argumentative in my post, and I will try to remain so here. I thought that I very clearly stated that the lack of distinctiveness during play was what me and my group experienced. Its literally impossible to tell me that my experience was otherwise.Yet, thats what this reponse does. You say, with no personnel qualificationIts like saying &quot;You experienced it wrong&quot;. How is that even possible? I would accept this response if it was more like&quot;My own experience was that the results of those powers are as different as they come&quot;But not this statement you gave which i no way allows that I had a different experience to you.And this is just a poor analogy. It speaks purely of external observation and in no way encompasses experience. If I was to observe the rules, then yes, I would say that the classes were remarkably distinct. But I did actually say that in my post...by observation, they are distinct, I never said otherwise.Its actually the dead opposite situation. When I picked up 4e, what I saw was red and green and blue lights. After having played, what they felt like was just christmas lights.Im not a 4e basher. I wouldnt have played the game for so long if I was. In fact, I quite like the system. I am simply relating what happened to me and my group.Sorry, You cant tell me &quot;your experience was wrong&quot;.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="BobTheNob, post: 5951712, member: 82425"] I was very determined to not be argumentative in my post, and I will try to remain so here. I thought that I very clearly stated that the lack of distinctiveness [U]during play[/U] was what me and my group experienced. Its literally impossible to tell me that my experience was otherwise. Yet, thats what this reponse does. You say, with no personnel qualification Its like saying "You experienced it wrong". How is that even possible? I would accept this response if it was more like "My own experience was that the results of those powers are as different as they come" But not this statement you gave which i no way allows that I had a different experience to you. And this is just a poor analogy. It speaks purely of external observation and in no way encompasses experience. If I was to observe the rules, then yes, I would say that the classes were remarkably distinct. But I did actually say that in my post...by observation, they are distinct, I never said otherwise. Its actually the dead opposite situation. When I picked up 4e, what I saw was red and green and blue lights. After having played, what they felt like was just christmas lights. Im not a 4e basher. I wouldnt have played the game for so long if I was. In fact, I quite like the system. I am simply relating what happened to me and my group. Sorry, You cant tell me "your experience was wrong". [/QUOTE]

Verification