Cam Banks
Adventurer
The milestone mechanic is a good one to build off because it also encourages not resting immediately. Especially when you've just given someone a reason that certain days matter to them and others don't, that's reasonable.
Correct. And I don't want to jump into design with the assumption that the rules as presented are wrong. I'm working on the assumption that people will be using them, and I'm encouraging people to do so.
One nice thing about restoring the daily is that it feels more interesting than a static bonus. My concern is primarily around power.
I had considered the notion of getting back a utility power, and leaving the option for getting a daily attack power back to times of grand conjunctions (such as the Night of the Eye, when all three moons are aligned). That makes those occasions pretty special. Utility powers reflect an area of wizardry that can always do with more flex, and so if it's "get a utility power back after a milestone" for High Sanction and "can't use a utility power until you reach a milestone" the power balance might be better addressed.
Now, to take an entirely different tact - what if you did it something like expanded spellbook and said that the wizard had access to more spells during high sanction and less during low?
In 3.5, we set about providing the players who took the WoHS prestige class with a number of benefits, from a bonus to Knowledge (arcana) and Spellcraft just by being WoHS, to better research and lab access, and so forth. Expanded Spellbook sounds like a good thing for any mage to have, so I feel comfortable leaving it as it is and having them make decisions based on the existing feats. For instance, why come up with an all-new power or ability that does what a feat like Spell Focus does? They can take Spell Focus and be done with it.
Though none of those really affect a mage not adventuring, but neither does almost anything.
Right. I'm not really all that concerned with the mages who are sitting back in their Tower doing nothing. They get some minor benefits but that's about it, and really, that's cool with me.
Cheers,
Cam