Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="DarrenGMiller" data-source="post: 2521940" data-attributes="member: 23174">Here is my list (not in order):Hour of the Knife: Railroaded plot with a twist to guarantee the ire of every player at the table.Needle: Silly talking spiders that say, "Gee Whiz!" over. and over. and over.  Actually, this silliness and politically correct "young gamer/child friendly" phase of 2E was one of the things that made me stop playing for a while.  Any of them could make this list.The Silver Key: The PC's can stay trapped in other bodies forever, and likely will.Lost Island of Castanamir:  bad gimmicksSecret of Bone Hill: I know someone else praised this one, but my players were bored and confused.  We scrapped it quickly.Dragonlance:  based on novels. "Come on ride the train..."  We actually played the first nine adventures.Gargoyles: see NeedlePuppets: see NeedleHowl from the North/Five Shall Be One:  I bought these with great expectations of an epic quest, but discovered it was only a plot to destroy my favorite campaign setting!Curse of Xanathon: see NeedleNow on the other hand, here are some that we played and enjoyed: Expedition to the Barrier Peaks, Tomb of Horrors, Castle Greyhawk, Beyond the Magic Mirror and Dungeonland, Ravenloft, Egg of the Phoenix, Ghost Tower of Inverness.One final question:  If we subtract the nostalgia factor, would Keep on the Borderlands make this list?DM</blockquote>