Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="FrogReaver" data-source="post: 7453851" data-attributes="member: 6795602">Rulings not rules remember. If the DM and players both agree then it is a rule. Heck if the DM rules it the. It is a rule, although I'd prefer to include the players as well as it's really the social contract that holds it all together. there was nothing in the original agreement/contract that allowed for sudden regrowth of wings. If there were then no one here would habe an issue. The thread would have lasted like a page or 2. The player didn't choose just not to use the ability. Nor did the DM simply disallow the ability. They ageees the character would not have the ability and even created in game fiction around that (wing stubs). There was no agreement made that the player would be granted a class ability to remedy that situation. If there were then we would all be fine with that. Most of us like the outcome and would allow it for that reason. That still doesn't validate the methods used to get to that outcome. An agreement at the beginning that in the future the player could choose to regain that ability when cuz happens or when the player decides or whatever would have been sufficient.</blockquote>