Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="Maxperson" data-source="post: 7456660" data-attributes="member: 23751">They aren't.&nbsp; They are acting out the part of their particular character AND THEN they are narrating the response.&nbsp; Two different things, the latter of which cannot negate the former.Other than my saying at least 3 times that it was roleplaying PLUS something extra, which is explicitly saying that the narration of the other character is not a part of the roleplay&nbsp;This is flat out wrong.&nbsp; From what you have described, you don't roleplay one whit more than the guy who narrates the response.&nbsp; Both of you are acting as you character in response to what the character perceives, and so is that guy.&nbsp; That he then engages an extra meta ability that you don't have doesn't negate his roleplaying, which fits the first roleplaying definition exactly. To say otherwise is to engage in One True Wayism.&nbsp; You are saying that the way you act in character in response to what the character perceives is right, and when he acts in character in response to what the character perceives he is wrong.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="Maxperson, post: 7456660, member: 23751"] They aren't. They are acting out the part of their particular character AND THEN they are narrating the response. Two different things, the latter of which cannot negate the former. Other than my saying at least 3 times that it was roleplaying PLUS something extra, which is explicitly saying that the narration of the other character is not a part of the roleplay This is flat out wrong. From what you have described, you don't roleplay one whit more than the guy who narrates the response. Both of you are acting as you character in response to what the character perceives, and so is that guy. That he then engages an extra meta ability that you don't have doesn't negate his roleplaying, which fits the first roleplaying definition exactly. To say otherwise is to engage in One True Wayism. You are saying that the way you act in character in response to what the character perceives is right, and when he acts in character in response to what the character perceives he is wrong. [/QUOTE]

Verification