Your opinion on Light and Darkness interaction?

[sfedi]

Mmm. I see.

 

[DrSpunj]

The big problem with countering is, that you need to be in range, and the range is touch.

Right! That's the RAW, but it basically makes countering a non-option, IMO, which I'm never a big fan of.

I think if this came up IMG I'd allow a Spellcraft check before entering the darkness effect to determine the center of the effect, then allow the caster to successfully counter the darkness spell if they cast their light spell on the appropriate vertex/square...at Touch range, of course.

Would anyone do it any differently? And if so, how & why?

Thanks.

DrSpunj

 

[Thanee]

To be honest, I regard countering and dispelling as completely irrelevant here. I don't think anyone would ever want to do that.

Bye
Thanee