By "thematically similar" I didn't quite mean the same game all over again. More of a "ordinary people in an ordinary world with extraordinary abilities" similarity. Doing a reset might be kinda weird.
Hmmm. Could be interesting, too. I gotta say, the school setting is great, lots of mentors and peers to play with as a GM.
There is familiarity in the setting, too. That's both good and bad. It's good to have everyone familiar with the setting, but not so much with the plot.
Then again, I'd change a lot of stuff up. Paragons has some cool concepts that would fit into the Legacy universe really well. Probably start at a lower PL, make whole setting lower PL to ground it a bit more. I think a complete reset would be in order, starting at the middle somewhere might be even more confusing. I'd probably keep some NPCs, change others, add new ones. Heh, Ultimate Generation Legacy, if you will.
Huh, this would be doable if everyone was up for it. It wouldn't be the same thing all over again. Just starting with the similar basic assumptions and taking it in different directions from there.
Bialaska, I think I'd like to cap number of players to start with at 6, so if less then that come back, you're first in line to grab a spot, if you like.