I can't begrudge Greyhawk for winning, but it seems to me more like the consensus / compromise position rather than a majority preference.
And I've never seen as much mindless Planescape boosterism as I have anti-Planescape grumbling.
How does dislike for Planescape invalidate that Greyhawk is currently polling a majority in this poll? If they don't like PS, if they're going to vote (not voting is always an option if you don't like either choice) for the alternative. Moreover, is there something about Planescape grumbling that makes it invalid? I don't like the patois Planescape affected and didn't bother buying much of the product line despite liking the DiTerlizzi art a lot. Reading the material was just too much of an irritation. So of course I'm not going to vote for PS against any campaign setting I like better. Is there something wrong with posting that opinion?
That kind of matches the broader reality though. That's why it was chosen as the default for 3e, not because it's the best setting ever dreamed up, but because everyone can live with it.I can't begrudge Greyhawk for winning, but it seems to me more like the consensus / compromise position rather than a majority preference.
Even cannibal halflings....?That kind of matches the broader reality though. That's why it was chosen as the default for 3e, not because it's the best setting ever dreamed up, but because everyone can live with it.
Even cannibal halflings....?
Wait! If you vote Planescape, I will offer your character the Head of Vecna!
Nice try, but [MENTION=94712]Lindeloef[/MENTION] will be playing in my campaign! But thinking about it ... I could throw in several more body parts of Vecna as well. there might be some unforeseen side effects if one combines them, though.
I can't begrudge Greyhawk for winning, but it seems to me more like the consensus / compromise position rather than a majority preference.
And I've never seen as much mindless Planescape boosterism as I have anti-Planescape grumbling.