OOC: I'm for selling everything. If anybody wants one of the items, we should pretend like we sold it, split the liquidated amount, and then charge that person the cost of the sold item (had we actually sold it).
The wand could be tricky. It's not worth identifying, but it's only worth 25gp without identification. Fimble would be willing to pay some of his share for the wand, because it'll be useful and cheaper than normal. Perhaps 50gp? Is there any conceivable way to sell it for more than 25gp? And if Fimble gets it, I suppose I'll need to know how many charges are left on it, so when Fimble uses it, I can play correctly.
Also, what are we doing about Metrius? He didn't really help in taking Drezel down, though he did have a hand with Otto and the rest of the adventure. IC, it makes no sense not to split the treasure with him.