D&D 5E Survivor Campaign Settings- Birthright Wins?

[MechaPilot]

Birthright 20
Blackmoor 17
Council of Wyrms 14
Dark Sun 20 (-3)
Dragon Fist 16
Ghostwalk 15
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 20
Mahasarpa 11
Mystara 20
Nentir Vale 17
Pelinore 14
Planescape 20
Ravenloft 11 (+1)
Spelljammer 10
Thunder Rift 18
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 18

Because Dark Sun requires tedious resource management that I usually skip over unless it's absolutely necessary.

 

[Gonat]

Birthright 20
Blackmoor 17
Council of Wyrms 14
Dark Sun 20
Dragon Fist 16
Ghostwalk 15
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 20
Mahasarpa 11
Mystara 21 My first RPG setting
Nentir Vale 17
Pelinore 14
Planescape 20
Ravenloft 11
Spelljammer 7 because I've always wanted to play but never got to...
Thunder Rift 18
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 18

 

[Duan'duliir]

I woke up this morning to find Eberron killed. I shall now take my revenge by downvoting that which the murderer upvoted until it dies.

Birthright 20
Blackmoor 17
Council of Wyrms 14
Dark Sun 20
Dragon Fist 16
Ghostwalk 15
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 20
Mahasarpa 11
Mystara 21
Nentir Vale 17
Pelinore 14
Planescape 17
Ravenloft 11
Spelljammer 8 As it is the alternative to Planescape, I think this is appropriate
Thunder Rift 18
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 18

 

[CanadienneBacon]

Goodness, if I'd known that, I would've upvoted Dark Sun.

 

[Mefistofulee]

Birthright 20
Blackmoor 17
Council of Wyrms 15 In hopes that all the dark sun fans will attack my upvote
Dark Sun 17 I am so sick of hearing about dark sun and Psionics
Dragon Fist 16
Ghostwalk 15
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 20
Mahasarpa 11
Mystara 21
Nentir Vale 17
Pelinore 14
Planescape 17
Ravenloft 11
Spelljammer 8
Thunder Rift 18
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 18

Edit: made the upvote green instead of red

 

[doctorhook]

Some stats and corrections:

Name #Score# (Votes For/Votes Against)
Birthright 20 (+3/-1)
Blackmoor 17 (+3/-2)
Council of Wyrms 15 (+1/-2)
Dark Sun 17 (+21/-8)
Dragon Fist 16 (+2/-2)
Dragonlance 0 (-7)
Eberron 0 (+22/-14)
Forgotten Realms 0 (+1/-7)
Ghostwalk 15 (+1/-2)
Greyhawk 0 (+6/-9)
Jakandor 14 (-2)
Kingdoms of Kalamar 0 (-7)
Lankhmar 20 (+3/-1)
Mahasarpa 11 (-3)
Mystara 21 (+1)
Nentir Vale 17 (-1)
Pelinore 14 (-2)
Planescape 13 (+8/-5)**
Ravenloft 11 (+12/-7)
Spelljammer 8 (+3/-5)
Thunder Rift 18 (+1/-1)
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 18 (+1/-1)

**NOTE: There were two errors in the Planescape tally, from posts #87 and #113. Planescape's score had been accidentally inflated by 4 points. The tally is correct as of this post.


ORDER OF ELIMINATION

1. Forgotten Realms Eliminated by the 22nd vote cast (post #38)
2. Dragonlance Eliminated by the 36th vote cast (post #58)
3. Greyhawk Eliminated by the 70th vote cast (post #111)
4. Eberron Eliminated by the 77th vote cast (post #119)
5. Kingdoms of Kalamar Eliminated by the 80th vote cast (post #122)

As before, my own vote will follow in the next post.

 

[doctorhook]

Birthright 20
Blackmoor 17
Council of Wyrms 15
Dark Sun 17
Dragon Fist 16
Ghostwalk 15
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 20
Mahasarpa 11
Mystara 21
Nentir Vale 17
Pelinore 14
Planescape 10
Ravenloft 11
Spelljammer 9 Any day over Planescape
Thunder Rift 18
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 18


REQUIESCAT IN PACE, Eberron.
You were too good for this thread.

 

[Kite474]

Birthright 20
Blackmoor 15 - Really because of just how un-unique it is.
Council of Wyrms 15
Dark Sun 17
Dragon Fist 16
Ghostwalk 15
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 20
Mahasarpa 11
Mystara 21
Nentir Vale 17
Pelinore 14
Planescape 11 - It's video game is one of the best PERIOD! Hell better than BG!
Ravenloft 11
Spelljammer 9
Thunder Rift 18
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 18

 

[doctorhook]

Blackmoor 15 - Really because of just how un-unique it is.

Psst! That should be a 14.

 

[CanadienneBacon]

Birthright 20
Blackmoor 14
Council of Wyrms 15
Dark Sun 17
Dragon Fist 13 -- Yup, still has the word "Dragon" in it.
Ghostwalk 16 -- So this one sounded vaguely familiar. I read up in it and remembered super really wanting to play it, and sort of fell in love all over again as I re-read. I will probably offer a 5e PbP set here.
Jakandor 14
Lankhmar 20
Mahasarpa 11
Mystara 21
Nentir Vale 17
Pelinore 14
Planescape 11
Ravenloft 11
Spelljammer 9
Thunder Rift 18
Wilderlands of High Fantasy 18