4E Class Survivor - Round 4

[Invisible Stalker]

That would be Class Idol and yes, I think that might change things around. The least disliked is not necessarily the most liked.

I swear if the warden sings "Ain't No Mountain High Enough," one more time, there's going to be trouble.

 

[Tallifer]

What sort of singer would your bard be?

I would like to think of a bard as an heroic Gaelic harpist with a barbaric bronze sword and woad and trews and red braids, singing and roaring with a voice of thunder...

But whenever the word bard pops in my head I unintentionally imagine Elan singing in a falsetto castrato voice and doing Bollywood dance moves to illustrate his words.

 

[Cadfan]

That would be Class Idol and yes, I think that might change things around. The least disliked is not necessarily the most liked.

Anyone want me to do it? I'll run it like America's Got Talent. You can vote up to X times (honor system not to vote more), and then the bottom Y percent drops out each round.

 

[I'm A Banana]

Anyone willing to make a variant Survivor Round System based on love, not hate?

GET A JOB, HIPPIE. You're German, man! You are putting every German stereotype over here to shame!

...I guess unless you're one of those doughy chocolate-Germans. But they're practically Swiss.

Is that what you want to be, Mustrum? Swiss?

Hippie.



[PS: A Vote for Warden is a Vote For Less Insanity; I actually like the 4e bard, though I don't disagree with the criticisms here]

 

[Garthanos]

Invoker hate pains me. I love this class.

Anyone willing to make a variant Survivor Round System based on love, not hate? Might be interesting to see whether that changes anything?

In fact I haven't voted at all as this is too negative... ;-)

 

[mach1.9pants]

I feel like I am repeating myself :ROGUE!

 

[yesnomu]

I feel like I am repeating myself :ROGUE!

What's there to dislike about the Rogue? It's the best-balanced PHBI striker, and a pretty cool all-around class.

 

[gribble]

Anyone want me to do it? I'll run it like America's Got Talent. You can vote up to X times (honor system not to vote more), and then the bottom Y percent drops out each round.

If you were going to do that, I'd rather see "one man, one vote". Each round you get to vote for the one class you like most - why muddy the waters with multiple votes?

 

[ZzarkLinux]

Vote (off) boring. Die, ranger, die!

My vote agreed with this.
: It's a boring concept: FIGHTER + FOREST RANGER.
: Twin Strike throws balance to the wind.

There is another class near identical to this.
It's in PHB2 and has the DIVINE power source...

 

[FireLance]

Anyone want me to do it? I'll run it like America's Got Talent. You can vote up to X times (honor system not to vote more), and then the bottom Y percent drops out each round.

Sure, but as gribble said, I'd prefer one vote per voter and one class voted off per round. I think it would also be a better idea to do this a month or two after Class Survivor is over, to minimize the chances that people will vote Survivor-style (for the one they want to go) instead of Idol-style (for the one they want to win).