Tony Vargas
Legend
Sure, but a lot of us have been here since it was Eric Noah's and all about the 'new' 3rd edition, and have just adopted each new edition, 4e, then 5e, in turn.I have to say I'm a bit surprised that 4E is leading in the poll here. Not because I dislike 4E (I like it, actually) but because I had gotten the vibe that this forum leaned more anti-4E compared to RPG.net, where at the moment there are five (at least) Let's Read threads for various 4E products.
What's your favorite alternate to the current ed is often a close call. I nearly voted 4e, but went with 1e, because that's still where the magic lies, for me, emotionally. I could have as easily gone for 4e (pre-E), on the basis of technical superiority, or 3.0 for the character concepts I was able to build to.