I thought it was obvious I meant he is not magical in the narrative (where he works alongside people who actually use magic or have actual super powers).
Oh, well.
But that's just saying that anything you decide is not supernatural is not supernatural because you've decided it isn't based on your narrative. Words becomes meaningless if you do that.
By that same logic, nothing in D&D is supernatural because magic is not unnatural in that world. Magic is supernatural in our world because it doesn't exist. Supernatural means "above or beyond what is natural; unexplainable by natural law or phenomena" in a world were magic exists it is explainable as a magical phenomena. It also strips all useful meaning from the word.
Gah ... and here I go with my "blah, blah, blah". Dang writer's block.
