The Book of Boba Fett (spoilers)

Then turning tail and hiding when the empire is formed instead of attempting to actually help the rebellion fight back against a brutal dictatorship that they were at LEAST partially responsible for helping cause. And that's just in the Lucas-directed movies.

They went from hundreds of Jedi down to a handful because of Order 66, so what were they supposed to do when they were just smashed and murdered by the Sith running the Republic? The good guys lost the war in the prequel trilogy and had to wait nearly 20 years for the unlikely events of the original trilogy to happen before the Empire could finally be defeated.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

So the thing to remember is that when Lucas designed the force it wasn’t the modern ying/yang concept we love today, it’s more like white snow trying to remain pure from darkness.

the concept is that giving in to emotion and attachment ultimately leads towards evil. People can tolerate it to a certain extent, but the corruption is inevitable.

One of the absolute best renditions of this was Jacen Solo from the legacy books. Jacen tries to go grey, not believing in a good side and bad side. And he is so careful, constantly checking his motives and his rationalizations. And yet the reader gets to the corruption, it’s slow,
Taking place over several books, but in the end he succumbs.

you could argue that the tragedy of Star Wars is the inevitable corruption of power, that the Jedi only stay “good” by giving up the very things a normal person would consider barbaric, because Normal people would be too corrupted by the power they wield
Arthurian Tales type stuff. There's only one problem with that. Arthurian Knights also fell "to the dark side." The bough that refuses to bend, instead breaks.
 

They went from hundreds of Jedi down to a handful because of Order 66, so what were they supposed to do when they were just smashed and murdered by the Sith running the Republic? The good guys lost the war in the prequel trilogy and had to wait nearly 20 years for the unlikely events of the original trilogy to happen before the Empire could finally be defeated.
Yeah, they got nearly annihilated. By the army of cloned child soldiers they decided to use to crush a rebellion against the Republic. After they failed to perform coup d'état against Senator Palpatine. For a legitimate reason, but it's not like they tried to let anyone outside the Order know that.
 

Yeah, they got nearly annihilated. By the army of cloned child soldiers they decided to use to crush a rebellion against the Republic.
Yeah, that part's always bugged the hell out of me. But it's not just the Jedi - literally nobody in the Republic seems to have a problem with breeding a race of cannon fodder to fight their war for them.
After they failed to perform coup d'état against Senator Palpatine. For a legitimate reason, but it's not like they tried to let anyone outside the Order know that.
It's not as though doing so would have made the slightest difference. This is the guy who successfully orchestrated both sides of a galactic conflict. Going up against him in a propaganda campaign would be a hopeless gesture.
 

Yeah, that part's always bugged the hell out of me. But it's not just the Jedi - literally nobody in the Republic seems to have a problem with breeding a race of cannon fodder to fight their war for them.
They didn't exactly breed them themselves. It was more that the Republic was getting its butt kicked by the Separatists until Obi-Wan discovered that someone had ordered a clone army in their name and no-one looked a gift Trojan bantha in the mouth.
 

It's not as though doing so would have made the slightest difference. This is the guy who successfully orchestrated both sides of a galactic conflict. Going up against him in a propaganda campaign would be a hopeless gesture.
Even if they couldn't win the propaganda war, it probably would have been good for anybody who rebelled against him to know that he was a Sith lord who could shoot lightning from his fingers.
 

Even if they couldn't win the propaganda war, it probably would have been good for anybody who rebelled against him to know that he was a Sith lord who could shoot lightning from his fingers.
And how do you tell them? Even if they'd broadcast it across the galaxy it would've been just another rumour spread by the remnants of a traitorous organisation. 20 years later, Imperial propaganda has been so effective that practically nobody even knows what a Jedi is.
 

If they could find a younger actor to take the role, should Luke become a reoccurring character? Would his own show work? Would feature films be a better fit? I think at some point they will have to move away from the CGI Luke.

Many moons ago, I attempted to run a Star Wars d20 game. One of the players didn't like the idea of cameos from characters from the movies. He felt they would just take over. Also, the GM wouldn't do them justice as NPCS. Did it feel that way with Luke here? Was it just right?
 

20 years later, Imperial propaganda has been so effective that practically nobody even knows what a Jedi is.
Which in and of itself is dumb. Even among humans, 20 years isn't enough for most of the race to die out, let alone forget something that was common knowledge. And then there are the myriad of races that live even longer. Almost everyone would still know what a Jedi was, propaganda or no.
 

Which in and of itself is dumb. Even among humans, 20 years isn't enough for most of the race to die out, let alone forget something that was common knowledge. And then there are the myriad of races that live even longer. Almost everyone would still know what a Jedi was, propaganda or no.

It was kinda supposed to be more like 50 years but Lucas changed his mind apparently.

The 80's lore such as it was got incorporated into the Thrawn Trilogy and 90's EU.

But Vader as Luke's old man didn't make that much sense. Once again Lucas changed his mind.

Origin Nally the cliners were revolting against the republic and the Clone Wars were republic vs the cloners.

They even went as far as a canceled Kenner toyline 1985/86 iirc.

So I guess Lucas was back and forth on things from around 1974-1997/98.
 

Remove ads

Top