D&D (2024) What Magic: the Gathering setting would you like to see next?
New Phyrexia. It's the unholy spawn of Eberron and Ravenloft; what's not to like?
Though actually, I could really get into a post-Bolas Amonkhet. A ruined desert world full of zombies and mummies, with a handful of survivors trying to find a home... tons of adventure potential there.
Though actually, I could really get into a post-Bolas Amonkhet. A ruined desert world full of zombies and mummies, with a handful of survivors trying to find a home... tons of adventure potential there.
Charlaquin
Goblin Queen (She/Her/Hers)
I’d really rather they drop the M:tG crossover, as I don’t think they’re a good fit for each other. But if they must, I guess Dominaria is the plane I would dislike the least.
Gradine
The Elephant in the Room (she/her)
I have never heard of New Phyrexia until just this moment, but it's got my vote
Top 3:
1. Kamigawa
2. Eldraine
3. Amonkhet
Runner's Up: Capenna, Ixalan and Kaladesh.
I like the mix of fantasy and sci-fi cyberpunk that the latest Kamigawa set offered. Overall, I think any of these 6 offer something interesting that could make an interesting campaign setting.
1. Kamigawa
2. Eldraine
3. Amonkhet
Runner's Up: Capenna, Ixalan and Kaladesh.
I like the mix of fantasy and sci-fi cyberpunk that the latest Kamigawa set offered. Overall, I think any of these 6 offer something interesting that could make an interesting campaign setting.
I only started playing in 2015ish, with Battle for Zendikar. The older planes haven't sparked much interest. Maybe if they get a new set?
Charlaquin
Goblin Queen (She/Her/Hers)
It was originally Mirrodin.
CrashFiend82
Explorer
As someone with no MTG experience just having read up on the various worlds, there a number I would love. Currently from this group I would go Kamigawa since it would push D&D into some interesting places.
I think Ixalan is great but it would need a few passes by some sensitivity writers. The colonizers being vampires is interesting and the indigenous populations seemed made with love love however they felt like "noble savages" a bit too much. Tarkir sounds interesting but could also be problematic if not handled well. I would love a Norse Kaldheim setting focused around giants as well. WOTC just needs to focus on what makes each plane unique and lean in hard.
I think Ixalan is great but it would need a few passes by some sensitivity writers. The colonizers being vampires is interesting and the indigenous populations seemed made with love love however they felt like "noble savages" a bit too much. Tarkir sounds interesting but could also be problematic if not handled well. I would love a Norse Kaldheim setting focused around giants as well. WOTC just needs to focus on what makes each plane unique and lean in hard.
Similar Threads
