D&D (2024) What, exactly, is a 5e "scimitar"?

Charlaquin

Goblin Queen (She/Her/Hers)
While the samurai wore daisho, it was extremely rare for them to wield daisho. The two swords simply have two different functions, and most of the idea of a katana-in-one-hand and a wakizashi-in-the-other is assumed by people without a full picture of how they were used. It's more likely that a katana would be used one or two handed as a primary weapon and the wakizashi as a backup, or for close quarters fighting, or for other uses.

Two-weapon fighting just wasn't done that much in history anywhere. Because it's frankly hard to do, and most people lack the coordination to ever get very good at it no matter how hard they try.
A katana probably wouldn’t have been used as a primary weapon either in battlefield situations. In duels, sure, but on the battlefield you’d probably want a polearm like a naginata, with a katana as backup. The wakizashi then was the backup to the backup, and perhaps used in grappling situations.
 

log in or register to remove this ad

Charlaquin

Goblin Queen (She/Her/Hers)
I just wish they'd call it that. They didn't keep "Broadswords" or "bastard swords" not sure why they keep "studded leather".
Because the iconic images of the fantasy rogue and ranger wear leather clothing (not even cuir bouilli) and they need something to upgrade their “leather armor” to that fits that depiction.
 

Bill Zebub

“It’s probably Matt Mercer’s fault.”
I just have to pretend it’s a brigandine

Oh, I don't! I imagine it's exactly what it sounds like: leather armor with metal studs embedded in it. It's effective as armor because the tears and wails of historical accuracy nerds, in aggregate, are sufficient to bend space time and deflect weapons. Just enough to get that +1.
 

Why stop with studded leather, we need studded chain. Studded plate. Studded studded armor. Think of the possibilities!
GIF by Tokkingheads
 






Gorck

Prince of Dorkness
Oh, I don't! I imagine it's exactly what it sounds like: leather armor with metal studs embedded in it. It's effective as armor because the tears and wails of historical accuracy nerds, in aggregate, are sufficient to bend space time and deflect weapons. Just enough to get that +1.
I just picture Studded Leather as bedazzled leather that is so shiny it distracts the attacker, thus granting the additional +1 AC
 
Last edited:

Remove ads

Top