D&D General Forgotten Realms - why do you still like running games here? +

A positive post about this setting which is simultaneously legendary and divisive. Over the decades we've read endless posts about the high level PCs (overblown, imo), the world shattering events, the neverending pages of canon that weigh the setting down etc. etc.

Yet many people still game here. Some never left.

So for those of you who still choose to run their games here:

1. Why
2. How do you approach the setting (everything is in, stick to one edition, gray box only etc.)?
3. How long has it been your campaign setting of choice?
4. What are your favorite game supplements?
5. Do you like any of the novels? Which ones? And do you use the novels for game material?
 

log in or register to remove this ad

A positive post about this setting which is simultaneously legendary and divisive. Over the decades we've read endless posts about the high level PCs (overblown, imo), the world shattering events, the neverending pages of canon that weigh the setting down etc. etc.

Yet many people still game here. Some never left.

So for those of you who still choose to run their games here:

1. Why
2. How do you approach the setting (everything is in, stick to one edition, gray box only etc.)?
3. How long has it been your campaign setting of choice?
4. What are your favorite game supplements?
5. Do you like any of the novels? Which ones? And do you use the novels for game material?
1. Maybe comfort and familiarity, but I just enjoy the setting.
2. Everything is in, I use 5e info, but a lot of my general descriptions etc are probably based more around my 3e understanding than anything else.
3. Maybe 28 years?
4. The 3e FRCS, 3e serpent kingdoms, 3e silver marches.
5. Yes i like a lot of them, soft spots for second Moonshae trilogy, the Avatar trilogy (I like Cyric), Cleric quintet, the Drizzt novels and spinoff featuring Artemis Entreri, Elaine Cuninghams novels, the Cormyr saga, the Erevis Cale trilogy. They help provide me the feel of the realms for when playing in or describing to players.
 

Why? I run games in FR because it is a near-endless spring of ideas. Many brilliant designers, creators, novelists and worldbuilders have labored on FR, each adding a twist or bit, and now I'm spoiled not only for adventure ideas but by variations of the campaign setting. There's a kernel in each major character, nation, faction, or region that will interest you, even if you discard the rest.

How do you approach the setting? What I like is in; what I don't is not. I twist, change, pick and choose at my own liking. That way, the long history ceases to become a chain and becomes a toolbox. I lean into the aspects that interest me, steal from other settings, change bits here or there that I think make it more evocative, etc. I do forbid my players from browsing the FR wiki and enforce such forbiddance stringently; any knowledge they get about the setting comes from me.

How long has it been your campaign setting of choice? As a dungeon master, probably going on about 6 years. I used to homebrew, then I used other published settings, and eventually I settled on FR.

What are your favorite game supplements? If we are sticking to 5e, Waterdeep: Dragon Heist has been my favorite adventure to run, ever. What a blast; the book is so full of hooks one could play it forever. I make extensive use of 5e's adventures as toolboxes, especially the ones published during Mike Mearls' time as head of the D&D team. Each adventure doubled as a very well-realized mini campaign setting, and that is probably a testament to the team but especially to Chris Perkins, who wrote most of them.

Despite the disappointment that is the SCAG, we have had some sourcebooks that are mostly FR-centric and I do use extensively, but could also be used in other settings: Volo's Guide to Monsters and Mordenkainen's Tome of Foes have fantastic chapters at the front that really help me bring peoples, monsters and different races to life. I love the random tables for hags, yuan-ti, etc., and I adore the discussions of elven metaphysics, dwarven clans, etc. These chapters were later sadly deleted in the reprinting, but I highly recommend them.

Minsc and Boo's Journal of Villainy is also very useful and full of gameable material within, including patrons, enemies, allies, rivals, cities, etc. The DMs Guild also sells other great third-party (but not necessarily canon, if you are one to care about such things) material, including Darkhold: Secrets of the Zhentarim and Ed Greenwood's Thay: Land of Red Wizards.

As for older stuff, I really 4e's Campaign Book, which is also full of ideas despite its horrible reputation. Actually, 4e's DM-focused line is mostly pretty great if you get past the endless retcons, including FR's Neverwinter and Mezoberranzan books. 3e had great supplements too (Powers of Faerûn was underrated), and of course 2e spoiled us with so many releases I probably haven't even glimpsed them all.

Do you use any of the novels? As inspiration, yes. I've read Salvatore, but what I found most useful were Erin Evans' books (Brimstone Angels), which feature tieflings, dragonborn, and warlocks. It really solidified some of those narrative beats in my mind. I mine novels for characterization, setting, and ideas, but I do not abide fully by its continuity at my table. My entertainment as a reader is separate from my worldbuilding as a dungeon master, and sometimes heroics in the novels delete adventure hooks best saved for the player characters.
 



I began the hobby in 1989 by buying the Mentzer version of Basic and Expert D&D with the original Forgotten Realms boxed set at Toys-R-Us. I taught myself how to play D&D using those 3 sets and then starting DMing for my friends. I like doing original boxed set with Waterdeep and Savage Frontiers supplements or doing the 3rd Edition Campaign Book with Silver Marches book as a start. I then will pull in anything that catches my fancy from other books or the wiki. I've read a few books but they are separate from my campaigns.
 

Various reasons.
1. Why not?

2. Generalllly whatever the current edition is doing. 4E exception Golarion filled the hole.

3. Off and on late 90s.

4. Faith's and Avatars trilogy, 3.0 FRCS, Serpent Kingdoms

5. Yes. Generally Elaine Cunningham ones and War of the Spider Queen. I don't use them for game stuff. Indirectly I do eg using a game product that references the novels.
 

I played 1e/2e starting with Under Illefarn adventure back when I first started being a DM. I liked the breath of information and the amount of detail in some places and still be allowed to add my things. The gods were there if you wanted or you could skip them like the super NPCs in the books. I seem to homebrew 3e and Nentir Vale/homebrew 4e. With 5e, I came back for ease with the Phandalin box set and kept playing in the same region with homebrew campaigns based there and in the surrounding area. There is still lots of information to find and use.

There might also be a small part for being able to place modules on DMsGuild for a few gold and use the lore of FR at will for this.
 

1. Why
My players and I enjoy it.

2. How do you approach the setting (everything is in, stick to one edition, gray box only etc.)?
We have been playing here since 1987. It's some sort of Grey box with 30+ years of homebrew lore and history at this point.

3. How long has it been your campaign setting of choice?
1987

4. What are your favorite game supplements?
Grey Box, 3rd Edition FR

5. Do you like any of the novels? Which ones? And do you use the novels for game material?
First couple of Drizzt and the Moonshae series of novels. Do not use for game materials.
 

I like doing original boxed set with Waterdeep and Savage Frontiers supplements or doing the 3rd Edition Campaign Book with Silver Marches book as a start.
A really solid foundation right there.

Also, a handful of comments on Serpent Kingdoms and the Cunningham books. I own Serpent Kingdoms but never really gave it much of a look and only read the Salvatore books (first 9 or so). Always meant to read the Niles Moonshae stuff but didn't get around to it.
 

Remove ads

Top