1QD's latest activity

Fizbin!

I am sorry that your scope of warrior is soo ... small and thusly tied to DnD's limited interpretation and expression. I might, if...

In counter of your "thin logic" label, I will respectfully disagree. Stealing something makes you a thief. Pulling out a sword and...

I think Robin Hood, Aladdin, Bilbo Baggins, Arsene Lupin, Charles Lytton, and Butch Cassidy may have also contributed just a tiny little...

So in most of my gaming experiences, rolling a Nat 1 was bad and a natural 20 was like double Dmg or something. In my own system, nat...

I can see why some people might like them, the roleplaying aspect being a main consideration for me. DnD has romanticized the thief, or...

I did briefly remove thieves from my 2e edit, replacing it with a light armoured skirmisher warrior (with the attack and hit dice of...

This was exactly my reasoning for taking them out. I do have a replacement but it covers many roles, not just thief. I just read a...

At the very least you need to acknowledge there are games that land well in a muddy ground in between. Any class based game with a...

Yes, but this thread isn't dedicated just to D&D. If you prefer, you can adjust my statement to "Everything is not about D&D, you...

If I mis-read then I apologize.

All true. Prior to mass manufacture people at least knew how to fix things, if not make them from scratch. I guess the claim I'm...

Literally the worst take on this I can think of. No where near the mark.

It would probably turn on how common/easy it is to do enchantment, but really, until you do the magical equivelent of mass manufacture...

I am taking by your response, you have a heavy DnD background?