AlViking's latest activity

Don't encourage them, there's a fairly large number of players in here who would take any chance they can get to make the game less fun...

I'm just waiting for the flood of players to rush in here with a deep sigh of relief, finally able to say how much they've wished that...

I think everyone who played any vudeo game with breakable weapons disagrees. There is nothing about dnd and fantasy that is evoked by...

I think it's probably better to have weapon vs. armor type differences or just give weapons different bonuses/penalties in different...

Doesn't really sound fun.

okay, this is fine and i can agree with this part, this however, is i feel a bad method to get to that solution, and i must ask, and i...

There are some players that will be unhappy if they aren't always getting what they want but in my experience it's primarily an issue...

I've had a lot of good experiences with public play and a handful of bad ones. I like seeing how other people approach the game and...

There are rules in PF for shield damage which is used quite often. Damage to weapons and armor is only supposed to occur if they are...

I guess that's simply something (rules penalties for casters) I've never seen. Then again a lot, but not all, of what I've seen has been...

I guess mileage varies. I've seen enough examples of elaborate and crippling spell-fumble systems over the years to disabuse me of the...

If the high quality weapons characters are assumed to have never break that is also consistent within the setting. If you want to add...

That's the thread we're in, though. The Op specifically didn't like GWM, so we have to assume the replacement weapons are ones that...

It was an attempt at humor. We don't have to be serious with every post.

Is it realistic though? A well made, high quality sword isn't just going to snap all of a sudden or the unlucky 1/20 time the dice don't...