Recent content by Committed Hero

  1. Committed Hero

    What Makes A Successful Superhero CAMPAIGN

    Player buy in is almost as important as in a horror game. At a minimum I would want all players to agree whether secret identities are important or not (since this affects the kind of personal stories you can use), and whether the heroes will be keeping to a moral code with respect to killing...
  2. Committed Hero

    Modern Action RPGs

    How much setting details does this contain?
  3. Committed Hero

    Call of Cthulhu: best 'scary' one shot?

    The horror reveal in the Delta Green scenario Convergence is the best I've ever experienced. It was CoC at the time it was released.
  4. Committed Hero

    What is a West Marches game?

    I expect you hand-wave the trip back to the haven.
  5. Committed Hero

    What are your thoughts on TTRPGs with non-standard dice?

    The d10 is a latecomer, probably because it's not a platonic solid. In some instances, the Genesys rules have you apply the dice results mathematically, but in others, they allow for narrative interpretation. So it can feel inconsistent. In play I thought Genesys handles large combats as well...
  6. Committed Hero

    Modern Action RPGs

    Outgunned would be the easiest. Night's Black Agents if you wanted supernatural elements (or don't mind using the mod in back for mundane action).
  7. Committed Hero

    What makes a successful superhero game?

    I can't say it any better that that, so I will add "mechanics that promote synergies in team fighting itself." Supers gaming suffers from a variation of James Bond's laser watch problem, where the emulation of other media in an rpg strains to operate. If a character has two powers, but one is...
  8. Committed Hero

    Best Horror Role Playing Game

    A class/level system has its benefits; the game distanced itself from them to its detriment.
  9. Committed Hero

    [Gumshoe] Merryshire Detective Club (a.k.a. Shires Out)

    Official announcement Merryshire Detective Club
  10. Committed Hero

    What’s going on at Gen Con this year?

    The One Ring starter set sold out, but there were still lots of 5e copies available on Sunday.
  11. Committed Hero

    Game Mechanics & Lore

    It's not necessary that the mechanics support the lore, but why wouldn't a designer strive for it? Unless there is a commitment to stay within a particular rules system - not an unwise decision, if that system is 5e - you have the wisdom of five decades of game writing to consider when creating...
  12. Committed Hero

    Call of Cthulhu: Sandbox

    The Armitage Files for Trail.
  13. Committed Hero

    Cthulhu By Gaslight Investigator’s Guide Shines A Light On A Classic Era

    The course to thread between providing comprehensive information and offering material that's good for use in the game is a narrow one. The difficulty is further compounded in this case because there are two earlier editions of a Gaslight sourcebook. Some grognards are apt to complain that they...
  14. Committed Hero

    dumb premise for a game - Medieval Aliens

    You can draw up plenty of similarities between alien abductions and fairy abductions - there's a switcheroo for unsuspecting players.
Top