Emerikol's latest activity

I don't stop the game. The player is having their character shake their fist at the gods for all it matters. If a player says: "Hey...

Why flip the table? Just tell the DM that you've decided his or her game is just not for you. Endless arguments suck the life out of a...

No. That is your implication. You think if I have an issue with a ruling I MUST say something. We all know as players that DMs make...

This is why a discussion can happen after the game is over. An hour long debate which in all honesty is never going to make much of a...

Again I don't care but stop trying to make out this playstyle which was almost the universal style at the games founding as radical or...

Yes. When it comes to declaring what is in the world, the DM is always right. If players want to discuss the rules of D&D after the...

I would have said, "Are you going to believe in this hunch your CHARACTER seems to have or are you going to believe your own eyes?"

If it is the DM, they do have the right to that power. I'd argue you are borderline leaving D&D without it. You definitely aren't...

The DM tells you what your senses reveal. He is your access to the world. The rules are a combination of childhood experience and...

I've done it both ways but I admit I don't understand the hatred of rolling stats. My groups were worried about surviving not shining...

That is our implied social contract. We see the DM as final arbiter of his campaign. We don't argue about that right but if we hate...

Then you may be the type of player that at least for me and my group is not a good fit. This sort of behavior is adjacent to rules...

I think if the person is taking their time in an ideal environment maybe you'd be right but this is often in the heat of combat and a...

I don't think obscure knowledge is appropriate to complain about to a DM or the group. It's like nitpicking a movie because you are a...

I believe that is the intent of D&D at it's founding and a fun playstyle for many of us. You can of course play differently.