Recent content by feartheminotaur

Your entire thesis on "I've yet to see a bad character" (on this or any thread - you say it a lot) is really a truncated "I've yet to see a bad character that's bad from my perspective" (or perhaps "that's bad in an objective sense") without considering the perspective of the player with the...

I like Jester Canuck's idea - use an attunement slot.

Depends...the first proper 5e game I played I was still thinking along AEDU lines and was shocked when only my player wanted to rest. "Uh, no one wants their encounter powers back?" I asked. Turns out the rest of the group was all Pathfinder players and didn't know what a short rest or...

Every FLGS or on-line game I've played is 'learned on the job'. In my long-running weekly game our DM builds our sessions so the level up is never mid-adventure (using the adventuring day/level rewards rather than per goblin killed). We do our leveling up between the 'chapters' but out of band...

I guess this, coupled with a comment a few back about divorcing the marks from feats, begs the question: How should the dragonmarks be done? I'd prefer they not be a feat as well; I'd like to see them tied to the character in some way as opposed to just picking one up at the DragonmarkMart. My...

I was discussing this thread (before it got, uh, bogged down and I just nope'd out of it) with another player in our weekly game who is prepping a weekend marathon game for his wife and college buddies. He had came to a similar conclusion when his wife was making her barbarian: Frenzy should be...

Although I'd feel better if you fixed the typo...

I singled out the warlock because that's what the thread is on about. This being a warlock thread is why I related just the anecdotal evidence about new-ish players kvetching about the warlock, and not any other class. Fighter and Action Surge and Monk and ki too, not to mention Clerics and...

And it's back! That's the Internet for you - with no context, are laughing with or at? I do think the biggest "inexperience player hates their warlock character issue" that I've personally encountered is a system problem - namely the class reliance on the short rest mechanic. It's tough to...

I think he means taking spells or invocations that sound and read cool but you find have little use in the particular game you're playing (as opposed to 'the game' in general). There's a huge difference between choosing spells and features you want and have interest in and those choices being...

Sure, and that's generally how I narrate it. And it holds true for a wizard versus a fighter, for example. It's just a disconnect between the different martial characters that I was referring to. Does a barbarian have less experience, or a paladin less training? Does their base class...

I like the idea behind the MDD because 'extra attack' has always been an aspect of the game that has never 'sat right' with me. In game it's "your 20 STR, 10 DEX Fighter can swing their giant sword more times than an 20 STR, 14 DEX Barbarian can? Or more times than a 20 DEX Rogue can stab...

Weird, I thought it was "polymorphed", but you're right, it's just "you turn into". I had it confused with the sheep one. I've actually never seen that one rolled. But if it's not polymorph what makes you think you'd retain stats and AC after the transformation, and not you literally turn...

Yep. It's a 2% chance that it'll go off (if an auto-roll, otherwise, a .1%), and based on party arrangement, probably much lower of a chance that it will affect the entire party. A half-ogre, a medium challenge for 4 1st level PCs, has a 55% chance of hitting an AC 15 player and, at 2d8+3, an...

Eberron is, to me, a high magic setting. Certainly magic items are more ubiquitous. The current 5e DMG offers items and suggestions for higher-level magic play, and a sorta system for items, but I'd like to see that go further for Eberron: Item creation rules, item pricing and rarity updated...