hawkeyefan's latest activity

Thing is too, in a long campaign like mine there might be a run of an adventure or two where I end up leading them by the nose, either...

But did you as GM “change” the fiction? You said earlier in the thread that it meant the farrier had always been there. I don’t think...

I disagree that this is semantics. If something is not determined, then it doesn't yet exist, and might never exist. That's not a state...

These two things have nothing to do with each other. The “Cunning Expert” character trait in @pemerton ’s game helps define that...

Like your farrier? So what?

That doesn't seem right. If the fictional reality is undermined and then it becomes determined, it becomes set not changed. As in it...

Well yes, but concern seemed about changing the reality of the fiction. However it's done, I don't have a problem with unsettled/...

But isn't it the same in combat in dnd? We make an attack, then fictional reality is undetermined until results of attack known. Plus...

I’m not sure what a Share GM is. As for the split of authority amongst GM and players, that varies by game. It really depends on what...

How do you know this? If someone was reading this thread and they had as little experience with games beside D&D and its close...

I have no idea what you are talking about. I don’t see the connection you’re making between a GM and player being on the same page about...

Believe me, there are zero people asking you to.

The players are expected to have a greater role and responsibility in helping create the fiction and push it forward, yes. If they...

Yes that’s true. No one said that it IS a railroad. The player and the GMbeing on the same page… in this case, both having a strong...

No, not at all. Most of what a GM does falls under the umbrella of “acceptable GM authority”. No, I think that generally, players want...