Hussar's latest activity

I'm not entirely clear what you mean here, but based on previous posts I will hazard a guess and say not necessarily. I think you can...

But it doesn't simulate the process of falling. It only tells you the result that you fell down. That's it. It could be gravity or it...

You are right that the rules don't need to give me that information. 100% agree. Simulation rules, OTOH DO. The rules are, in no way...

Again, this is perfectly fair. Totally agree. But, "unique combat system" is not part of simulation, it's an example of simulation...

Let's stick with the notion of First Person Shooters (FPS) games for am moment. Now, the mechanics of the game will determine how the...

The word you keep missing here is ANY It has to show ANY information. For something to be diegetic, it must inform the narrative...

Nice shifting goalposts there. Why did you fall? What happened? You failed the climb check and fell. The mechanics are entirely...

To me, it seems highly relevant to understanding free kriegsspiel that the referee is (or is intended to be) an expert in the activity...

The level of irony here is amazing.

Oh totally agree. It was a mistake to do it this way. That’s why they don’t do it this way any more. 🤷 What do you want? The...

No. That’s the straw man you keep insisting on. A simulation in no way must mirror reality. A simulation MUST reveal ANY information...

Which is fair to play that way. Perfectly fine. But nothing in DnD actually supports you. That dragon may have died because of wounds...

We have a language, a dictionary that drives what words mean, and the purpose of all that is to facilitate accurate useful...

This has come up a number of times, so, I'd like to pull this out once again. It's not about giving "detailed" results. It's about...

And I specifically said that if all someone is saying is personal preference, that would be fine. But several folks are not doing that...